| We often get questions and requests for technical support
from pilots who are interested in attaching some form of motor system
to one of our hang gliders. The following is intended to provide pilots
with answers to their questions, to the best of our ability.
The format of this information is a series of simple
statements in bold face type, each one of which is then further amplified
with additional explanation. If you’re in a hurry, read the bold type
statements. If you want a more in-depth understanding, read everything.
The information below is NOT provided for the purpose
of protecting us from liability, but rather for the purpose of giving
our customers accurate and important information. Please take it seriously.
Wills Wing does not recommend that any motor system
be used with any Wills Wing hang glider.
All Wills Wing hang gliders have been designed, developed
and tested for foot launched gliding and soaring flight. None of our gliders
has been designed, or tested with any consideration of the use of a power
system. We cannot, therefore, recommend the use of any such system with
our gliders.
Wills Wing does not provide any technical support
for the use of any power systems on Wills Wing hang gliders.
Beyond what we have written here, we cannot answer your
questions about attaching a power system to a hang glider. We would like
to be able to provide unlimited technical support on any subject to all
of our customers, but in practical terms, it simply isn’t possible with
the resources we have.
We don't have any specific information about what might
be required to attach any type of trike to any of our gliders. The manufacturer
of the trike system may be able to answer questions of this type. If a
manufacturer of a power system chooses to take the position, based on
their experience, that the use of their power system on one of our gliders
is appropriate and airworthy, then to the extent that you are willing
to accept their authority as the designer, and manufacturer of the entire
system, including the hang glider, and place your faith in their qualifications
in design, engineering, developmental flight test and product support,
you can give whatever weight to their opinions you choose.
We don’t have any specific information about attaching
or using a Mosquito harness to any of our gliders, other than the common
general information that it is necessary, according to the Mosquito manufacturer,
to remove any part of the keel which extends more than 1200 mm (47 inches)
behind the hang point. We do not have the resources to, and will not provide
answers to questions about which of our gliders would require relocation
of the rear wire attachment, or modifications to the sail in order to
comply with this, or what other problems may or may not arise in attempting
to use a Mosquito or mosquito-like harness. In very general terms, we
do know that with regard to the 1200mm requirement, the Falcon 195 and
225 don’t work, and that most high performance gliders do “work” in the
sense that the rear wire junction is less than 1200 mm aft of the hang
point. Because requests for custom parts require an inordinately large
allocation of technical support resources to process, we do not and will
not provide custom wire sets, or custom keels, or sleeving “kits” for
“Mosquito modifications.”
If you decide to put a motor package on a Wills Wing
hang glider, you have made the decision to become both an aircraft designer
and an experimental test pilot.
It is our opinion that it is not possible to develop
a motor package separate from the wing to which it is to be attached,
and end up with a tested, proven, airworthy flight system. Unless a full
engineering study and developmental flight test program has been conducted
specifically on a given model hang glider fitted with a specific motor
package, then, in our opinion, the combination of that glider and that
motor package is a purely experimental device of no known level of airworthiness.
Please note that a simple flight test, as in "Yes we have flown the
xxx model hang glider with the yyy model motor system and it flies fine,"
does not qualify as a developmental flight test program. Nor does the
experience of five, or even twenty other people who may have flown a given
glider and motor system combination, prove anything meaningful about the
airworthiness of that combination. Please note that this is not idle or
hypothetical speculation on our part. We have personally witnessed numerous
real world cases of seriously dangerous results of incomplete engineering
or inadequately tested systems in the application of various power systems
to hang gliders. If you install a power system on a Wills Wing glider,
you have chosen to become an aircraft designer and an experimental test
pilot. We support the right of anyone to choose to become a designer and
test pilot. (That is, after all, what we chose to be.) However, we are
very much opposed to people becoming designers and test pilots when they
are not aware that this is what they are doing.
Wills Wing cannot provide any meaningful information
about what modifications may be necessary to a hang glider in order to
safely use a motor system.
There are many possible considerations regarding the
effect of using a power system on the airworthiness of the glider, including
possible effects on static and dynamic stability, damping, control response,
and structural integrity. These effects can be very complex, and in some
cases difficult to evaluate, and we have not made any attempt to conduct
any such evaluation. Most pilots seem most concerned with the issue of
whether the glider is strong enough to carry the extra weight of the motor
system. In general, while this can be a concern, it is probably the least
significant concern, since certified hang gliders are typically designed
to a 100% structural safety factor when operated within the normal placarded
operating limitations. There may be important structural concerns that
relate to changes in the manner in which the glider is loaded, or to vibration,
fatigue, or other factors introduced by the application of a motor package.
Pilots interested in using trikes, for example, usually ask how strong
the keel is, and how much sleeving do they have to add to the keel to
make it strong enough. This is a question for which no simple answer exists,
and any answer at all to this question, even if “correct” would carry
the implication that addressing this concern would address any and all
potential structural issues, while in truth, it does not.
Proceed With Caution
All of the foregoing is not to say, or imply that it
is not possible to use a trike, or a Mosquito type harness on a hang glider
safely. Nor is it to imply that there is no value in the experience of
someone else who has used such a device on a hang glider. It is to say
that such experience has value only to a very limited extent, unless and
until it reaches the level of a full, competent, professional developmental
testing program. It is to say that the enterprise of aircraft design and
testing is, even for qualified professionals, measurably more hazardous
than is the normal use of a fully tested aircraft system.
If you decide to use a power system on a Wills Wing glider,
please proceed with extreme caution, and get as much information about
the proper use of the system as you can before you try to fly with it.
|